SCHILD’S LADDER – Greg Egan (2002)

Schild's LadderI have to say I didn’t think Australia’s Greg Egan to be an important science fiction author – I have seen a few mentions of his 1992 novel Permutation City in a few lists over the years, but that’s about it. He got a Hugo for a novella, but overall he’s not a prize winner, and there doesn’t seem to be a big buzz when a new title of his appears.

But all those parameters are social stuff, and Egan is “famously reclusive”. This excerpt from his website paints his character a bit: “I do not approve of the practice of using quotes from authors on book jackets, since I believe it blurs the distinction between advertising copy writing and reviewing. I’ve never provided such quotes myself, or sought them for my own books. However, because I neglected to tell my new editor at Gollancz how I felt about this, the UK editions of Schild’s Ladder have some comments by Stephen Baxter on the jacket, alongside the excerpts from bona fide reviews of previous books. This glitch was my fault entirely, of course, and I’ll do my best to ensure that nothing similar happens again.”

I like that. Egan seems to be rigorous, a man of principle, and he doesn’t care for commercialism – he also doesn’t attend conventions or sign books, for instance. But enough about the social: what about the writing itself?

In that regard, it’s also no surprise Egan isn’t really popular: he writes very dense, hard theoretical science fiction. Harder than Seveneves, to give you a benchmark. Much, much harder than Kim Stanley Robinson. Even Blindsight was a walk in the park compared to this. That’s also because Egan’s writing generally focuses on the hardest of hard science: mathematics and quantum theory. Other themes include the nature of consciousness, “genetics, simulated reality, posthumanism, mind transfer, sexuality, artificial intelligence, and the superiority of rational naturalism over religion.”

I have to say, based on reading Schild’s Ladder: Holy Moly, Egan is one of today’s most important writers of speculative literature, and those who like their stuff only light and fluffy are missing out big time. This is highly stimulating stuff. When I was 150 pages in, I went on a quarantine shopping spree and ordered 5 other of his books.

I used to think the Culture of Iain M. Banks represented the creative pinnacle of imagining a transhumanist future, but consider that position revised: it seems Egan has picked up the baton a long time ago.

Schild’s Ladder is a rich book, that deserves a thorough intellectual analysis, but I don’t feel like writing a lengthy text this time, so I’ll stick to the basics of a regular review. I’m sorry for the clunky format.

PROSE

Good, never gets in the way nor cumbersome. Maybe Egan uses the same formula of explicit similes a bit too much, but on the other hand, they always manage to illuminate what otherwise would remain abstract concepts. He’s also self-aware on the matter, one character exclaiming “I’m not an idiot. (…) You don’t need to spoon-feed me similes”.

CHARACTERS

Humans can live for millennia. Some have gone fully digital and ditched their bodies. The characters are not the focus of the book, but they are not lifeless cardboard either. The focus of the book is clearly the ideas. This does not mean Egan doesn’t understand human psychology – on the contrary. There is some neat stuff on living for hundreds of years, being acorporeal, free will, the effects of traveling to other star systems – there’s planet that goes collectively into “Slowdown” whenever somebody wants to travel for a couple of centuries, so they don’t fall out of sync.

STORY

Believe it or not, this is a page turner. It’s a variation on the BIG DUMB OBJECT story, but with a twist. The object is really, really big. In six hundred years, it has swallowed two thousand inhabited star systems, and it’s still growing. It’s the biggest big dumb object I’ve ever read about.

SCIENCE

It’s not fully clear what Egan’s mind-body problem solution is. He seems to sidestep this, and operates from the idea that we are just information translatable into all kinds of signals.

As the book deals with advanced quantum physics, a big part of the story obviously is speculation, and there’s even a big chunk of handwavium. This doesn’t mean the book has no merit scientifically, and Egan aims for consistency with the latest scientific insights. On his website, there’s heaps of theoretical stuff that complement his books.

POLITICS

Man, this also a great book on gender, albeit as a sideshow. It even has a few pages that function as a pastiche on all those other science fiction books that imagine future forms of gender norms & sexuality. Egan’s own solution is graceful, without any fuss.

Social Darwinism gets a walloping uppercut too.

ALIENS

It’s kind of a pissing contest: who can write the most alien aliens? Whose grasp on weird xenobiology is the best? What kind of strange alien language can I invent? Etc. Well, this book has the best alien aliens I have ever read about. They are not the focus of the book, mind you. I will not spoil more, but Egan has managed to truly think outside the box.

TOO DENSE OR NOT TOO DENSE?

I already wrote this was a page turner, yet it is also extremely dense hard SF. At times there are passages that went over my head. I’m absolutely no specialist, but in the last 25 years I think I’ve easily read over 1500 pages of non-fiction on quantum theory. So I’m not entirely uneducated on the matter either. I’m just saying, some parts of this book really deal with complex stuff.

The good news is that I could still enjoy the book without fully understanding its full theoretical scope. I have the hunch that if one would understand all the details, one’s admiration for Egan would increase more – a lot even.

As such, I think Egan managed something pretty unique: I think this book is both intellectually stimulating for both the quantum scientist and the layman. True, the quantum scientist will get the most out of it, but there’s so much good packed here, that the layman reader still feels to have hit a big vein of gold.

Obviously, not all laymen should enter. If you’re not willing to pay attention, and if theoretical matters don’t interest you, this is not the book for you.

By the way: dense doesn’t mean boring. There’s a great sense of discovery & wonder throughout, and it has elements of space opera, even a tad of horror in one scene. A couple of times the book is even outright funny.

VERDICT

I didn’t think I could still be surprised like this by science fiction. As an achievement of human intellect, imagination & creativity, Schild’s Ladder gets 5 stars, easily. As a reading experience I’d say 4 or 4.5: the ending is a bit rushed, the link with the title is underdeveloped in the characters, and I’m just a layman, so there’s that.

Highly, highly recommended.

 


Consult the author index for all my other reviews, or my favorite lists – including a non-fiction list.

13 responses to “SCHILD’S LADDER – Greg Egan (2002)

  1. Thanks for sending me this recommendation. It’s great when an author surprises you, isn’t it. I haven’t read any of Egan’s books but I remember hearing great things about “Blood Music.” This book sounds very intriguing and your enthusiasm is a perfect selling point. My only worry is the mathematics; not my strong point unfortunately. I think it could be too dense for me. But I’m willing to give it a try.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Don’t worry on the math, it’s only quantum physics in this book! Never heard about Blood Music, yet again something I’ll need to check out…

      Like

      • Blood Music is a Greg Bear novelette/expanded novel from about 1985 about biology run amok in an ambiguous way. Really great stuff and, even in the expanded form, it’s very concise.
        I’m a huge fan of Egan but I’m really impressed if this was your first Egan and you grokked it right away. My favorite of his, which is pretty mind-blowing and demanding, too, but has more points of contact, is Diaspora (though his collection, Axiomatic, is also way up there, along with others). I ultimately liked Schild’s Ladder but I actually had a hard time really engaging with it the way I did others. Took me a long time to read. 🙂
        Anyway, yes, you’re exactly right that Egan doesn’t do the things you’re supposed to do to become rich and famous but he is a major SF writer. It’s kind of like how two songs come out around the same time and one sells billions but is quickly forgotten while the other is not listened to by all that many at first but it keeps getting played and more and more people start listening and it becomes “classic rock.”

        Liked by 1 person

        • Haven’t read any Greg Bear. Will need to remedy that one day.
          I’m sure I didn’t grok Schild’s Ladder fully – I don’t grasp the title in relation to the world beyond the barrier for instance, but it seems to be there judging by other reviews.
          Diaspora is one of those 5 titles I bought, looking forward to it. I’ll probably read an Egan pretty soon, I tend to leave a lot of time in between books of the same author, but SL had something addictive to it. Good news that some of his other titles are a wee bit more accessible/relatable: that will make it even more addictive I guess.
          From SL alone it’s obvious that he’s a major SF writer. But still, if I just look at the stats foe the review, it’s one on the least read of my SF reviews this year. Obviously a highly problematic metric to judge by, so take it fwiw.
          Thanks for the elaborate comment, much appreciated!

          Like

  2. Egan is one of those authors I’m aware of but never checked out for details, and your review showed me that I might have overlooked an intriguing, thought-provoking writer. Granted, this story sounds like the opposite of the proverbial beach read, but challenging oneself is the kind of sport we must practice now and then… 😉
    I will add this books to my “wanted” list and hopefully not wait too long to see what it’s about – and thank you so much for sharing!!!!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Not a beach read, no, but really entertaining. Lots of his stuff seems OOP on paper btw, but nothing a library can’t fix I guess. (It’s about a physics experiment gone wrong, creating a swelling vacuum that devours everything. That’s the back cover info…)

      Liked by 1 person

  3. I never read anything by Egan, so this goes to my TBR right away – I don’t think I was ever disappointed by any of your recommendations, and this one got a very high recommendation indeed 😀

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I picked up an Egan book once, was intrigued by the description on the back, flicked through a couple of pages and saw … diagrams! It scared me so bad I’ve never picked up an Egan book since. I am too stupid for real science!!
    But now you’ve got me interested in spite of myself. This sounds so good. Still intimidating … but, maybe, just maybe … something I could read.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. I trust your opinion… I am not going to be afraid of the diagrams. 😆

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Pingback: THE GODS THEMSELVES – Isaac Asimov (1972) | Weighing a pig doesn't fatten it.

  7. Pingback: FAVORITE SCIENCE FICTION BOOKS | Weighing a pig doesn't fatten it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s