THE SANTAROGA BARRIER – Frank Herbert (1968)

The Santaroga BarrierI’m not too thrilled to write a review about this book. The Dune-series is among the best thing I ever read, so I hate to report that Frank Herbert didn’t even come close with The Santaroga Barrier. In short: this book is pulpy and feels dated. After about 100 of the 241 pages, reading it became a chore. The premise is interesting nonetheless, and Herbert manages to create an eerie vibe in the first couple of chapters.

Gilbert Dasein, a psychologist, is sent to invest the valley of Santaroga, a prosperous farm community that has no juvenile crime and no one smoking, and that doesn’t allow outsiders to buy or rent property, nor does it allow cheese, wine or other produce from outside to be sold. Two previous researchers both died of accidents during their stay in the valley. Dasein has, aside from his professional endeavour, a love interest in Santaroga too. He’s in love with Jenny, a girl he had a relationship with at his university. A few months before the story starts, she has moved back to her native town. The story is situated in the 1960s, somewhere in California.

Santaroga is mainly build like a mystery novel: what’s the deal with this town, and what’s the deal with those accidents? Plus, what’s the deal with those drugs!? Pretty soon it becomes clear that the Santarogans all eat something called “Jaspers”, a kind of drug. So, the book is a drug-novel too: references to LSD aplenty.

“Sometime you should feel the fur on the water,” her companion said. “It’s the red upness of the wind.”

Very soon, Dasein has a mysterious, near-fatal accident himself. At first, Herbert manages to convey the feeling of being an outsider quite well. I was engaged and interested. But the novel soon becomes formulaic: another accident happens, Dasein learns some tidbit of information, and yet another accident happens, new info, new accident, new info, new accident, etc. It shows that the story was originally published serialized in a magazine. After about 100 pages it becomes predictable and tiresome.  It’s also pretty obvious early on that Dasein himself will become an addict, turning him into a Santarogan too. And – sorry to repeat myself – the mechanism behind the accidents is also pretty obvious early on. So, the only thing left is the question what this Jaspers is. Well, it turns out it is something “between a virus and a bacteria” and “fungusoid in some respects”. That’s about it for the big reveal.

It doesn’t help that all characters are made out of cardboard either. Herbert writes a lot of lines wherein Jenny or Gilbert literally say “I love you”, but that doesn’t do it. I never, not once, felt that love come to life. It’s also very strange that the scholar Dasein has a hard time wrapping his head around the fact that he can’t betray this community and be part of it at the same time.

The book is not entirely without merit. Ideologically, I can relate to parts of it. There’s quite some critique on certain aspects of Western society, television, the influence of big business on politics, and so forth, the usual suspects.

“Justice,” Dasein said. “These sponsors you mention, and the government they control, are less interested in justice than they are in public order. They have stunted imaginations from too-long and too-intimate association with an ingrown system of self-perpetuating precedents. Do you want to know how they and their machinations appear to a Santarogan?”

But it’s all rather standard fare, sautéed in a sauce of philosophical Heideggerian mysticism about the Nature of Reality, and drugs opening the mind to the Unity of Everything. There’s also some unclear stuff about the nature of violence, instinct, education, the impossibility of objectivity, language and the nature of thought, and the relationship of all those things to civilization. It’s mostly disorganized, aphoristic rambling. That’s a shame, because these themes deserve better – surface references to Karl Jaspers and Heidegger (‘Dasein’) don’t do it either.

It’s also worth nothing that none of the back cover premise (no juvenile crime, no smokers, etc.) is actually explored: the relationship between a drug that creates a kind of fundamentally empathic, connected and honest mind, and a society consisting of these minds, is left underdeveloped. Aside from a few expositionary pages with speeches from the town’s doctor to Gilbert Dasein – scattered throughout the book – the focus of The Santaroga Barrier is fully on the creepy mystery story.

Were they really confident? he wondered. Or were they actors hypnotized by their own performance?

It’s not that you should avoid this book. It’s short and it’s an interesting document of its time. There’s worse stuff out there. I just can’t help shaking the feeling that Herbert was probably snacking on the local mushrooms a bit too much himself…

Click here for my other Herbert texts: long analyses of Dune, Dune Messiah, Children of Dune, God Emperor of Dune, Heretics of Dune & Chapterhouse: Dune, and more regular reviews of Destination: Void, Whipping Star, Soul Catcher & The Dosadi Experiment. I’ve also tackled Hunters of Dune & Sandworms of Dune, and wrote about Villeneuve’s 2021 film Dune: Part One.

Consult the author index for all my reviews, or my favorite lists.

Click here for an index of my longer fiction reviews of a more scholarly & philosophical nature, and here for an index of my non-fiction or art book reviews.

11 responses to “THE SANTAROGA BARRIER – Frank Herbert (1968)

  1. “Formulaic”, “Predictable”, “Tiresome”: three words I would not have thought could be applied to Herbert’s writing – at least judging by “Dune”. I never read anything else by him, and now I’ curious to sample another book, but probably not this one… 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    • The book plays out like a twilight zone episode. In context of its time and weird America it could be more relevant. But the ease and smoothness in Dune series is missing clearly as is their depth of developing the concepts. Like I said, its like a twilight zone ep. with some carlos Castaneda and other stuff thrown in. —My feeling is that he wanted to write something else. Nothing like dune.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. My advice would be to just keep on reading the Dune series. The scope becomes more epic every book, and I really like the philosophical stance that becomes clear throughout them (Leto’s Golden Path), culminating in God Emperor of Dune & the awesome Chapterhouse Dune. This was my first non-Dune Herbert book too, and I was a bit surprised too. I have second hand copies of The Dosadi Experiment, Soul Catcher and Whipping Star on my TBR-pile, so they should get a review here somewhere in the future. I still have high hopes for those, especially The Dosadi Experiment.


  3. Pingback: Vintage Goodies around the web-o-sphere | the Little Red Reviewer

  4. Pingback: DESTINATION: VOID – Frank Herbert (1965) | Weighing a pig doesn't fatten it.

  5. “It’s not that you should avoid this book. It’s short and it’s an interesting document of its time. There’s worse stuff out there. I just can’t help shaking the feeling that Herbert was probably snacking on the local mushrooms a bit too much himself…”

    Ha ha ha!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Book seemed like a prolonged 2-hr episode or series finale for the twilight zone.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Pingback: CHILDREN OF DUNE – Frank Herbert (1976) | Weighing a pig doesn't fatten it.

  8. Pingback: Weighing a pig doesn't fatten it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s